Visible Monday: Rocking a fake pashmina

Once you start wearing a big old shawl everyday, you’re on the express train to old ladyhood, right? Well, that’s what I’ve always thought.

So it was with mixed feelings that I fell in love with this cozy, oversized scarf the other day. We were sightseeing in a small town that we like to visit. It’s the perfect browsing town — quaint but not too sleepy, bustling but not harried, and very, very stylish, without being intimidating. It’s full of unique shops and galleries, brimming with items that we just don’t find at home.

And yes, there is money in this here town. So of course I wanted to hit the local consignment shop.

The shop was a bit unusual — small, with an odd mix of things. For clothing, I didn’t see much. There was some gorgeous amber jewelry, but that seemed a bit extravagant — I just wasn’t in the zone.

But there were a number of scarves.

As I tried them on, the store owner heard me voicing my old-lady fears. “I just sold a couple of these to some teenage girls, and they loved them,” she assured me. (And I must confess, the catty part of me briefly pictured hordes of teenage girls wearing the scarves with pajama pants and Uggs).

But I just fell in love with the scarf, so I bought it, for $13. I’m very happy with it, even though I know the whole thing may be a bit of a sham.

In the store display, the scarf was identified as a “silk pashmina.” The label says “55% pashmina, 45% silk.”

But the label is also glued in. It doesn’t say where it was made. And the “brand” name is, I kid you not, “Pashmina.”

Now, I wasn’t born yesterday. I know that glued-in labels are not a sign of top quality. I’m pretty sure that “Pashmina” is not a brand, and I also know that real pashminas are expensive. True, I didn’t know what “pashmina” meant until I looked it up online.  (It’s a cashmere-like fabric, for the record.  And apparently it’s so fragile, it could never stand up to a glued-in label).

Not surprisingly, my Internet search also revealed that there are a lot of fake pashminas out there. A veritable black market! Picture it, if you will:  furtive clusters of chilly, shawl-deprived women scurry into a dingy side street, seeking the hidden, forbidden, counterfeit pashmina shop.  (“Knock three times!  Tell ‘em Joe sent you!”)

Now, the store owner told me that this scarf was consigned, but she had a whole bunch of them. Was she being untruthful? Is her “source” a fake pashmina mill, rather than a wealthy dowager with shawls to spare?

Or — and I think this is more likely — did somebody in this small but stylish town order a bunch of pashminas online, only to be cruelly disillusioned when she realized they weren’t real?

Well, her disappointment is my gain. Because I love this scarf! It’s warm and cozy. The colors are rich and vibrant, the fabric soft yet substantial. And no, I’m not a fabric expert, but my current scarf collection includes some synthetics that feel lush as well as some natural fibers that feel skimpy or scratchy. The bottom line is: if it looks and feels nice, I don’t really care what it’s made of.

And at $13, I consider it a bargain, no matter how fake it may be. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve browsed scarves in chain stores — scarves in serviceable but unremarkable fabrics and patterns, repeated dozens of times over, scarf after identical scarf — priced at $30 and upwards.

In contrast, this scarf seems unique and striking. When I wear it, a certain kind of sumptuous, Old World glamour creeps in, and I start to feel very 19th-century Russian novel. It’s just the thing to feature for Visible Monday at Not Dead Yet Style!  (Be sure to visit the site to see what all the other stylish women are wearing to feel visible today).

So now I’m ready to rock my fake pashmina all over town.  Now, if only I could figure out how to remove the label without ruining it…

 How about you?  Do you love something that you know is “fake?”  

As a postscript, two of my favorite bloggers — Debbie at She Accessorizes Well and Serene at The Elegant Bohemian – recently awarded me with the “Liebster blog award.” They both have such wonderful blogs, and I’m so touched that they thought of me!

To be honest, kind bloggers have sent me awards once or twice before, but I’ve been reluctant to participate for various neurotic reasons. I worry, for example, that I’ll insult some great bloggers by leaving them out.  Or, I hesitate to break with my blog’s theme — such as it is — by tailoring a post to the blog awards.

But we small bloggers have to stick together, so I am participating in this one. Liebster means “dearest” in German, and this award is given to bloggers with fewer than 200 followers. Each recipient is asked to choose five other blogs to award. It was hard to choose which blogs to feature because there are so many good ones, and with the WordPress blogs, it can be hard to determine the number of followers.  But enough obsessing:  I had to choose, so here is my list.

  1. A Curious Girl’s Guide to Life - Gail is a British blogger who writes about a broad range of topics with a keen eye and playful sense of humor.  Plus, her David Bowie obsession is simply charming.
  2. Average in Suburbia - Very, very funny posts, as the title would suggest.
  3. Fashion Me Blog - Angie blogs from Greece, and I just love how she documents her process of creating interesting, low-cost outfits during troubled times.
  4. Hagfest - I can’t resist blogs with ironic titles spoofing our misconceptions about aging. Very funny.
  5. The Chronicles of Lady K - Kari and I joke about having been separated at birth.  I love her funny, self-effacing style as she documents the struggle to get oneself out of the house looking presentable.  I can relate!

These are all great blogs — check them out!

And to these five excellent bloggers:  if you choose to participate, the stipulations of the award are as follows:

1. Thank the giver and link back to the blogger who gave it to you.
2. Reveal your 5 blogger picks and let them know by leaving a comment on their blog.
3. Copy and paste the award on your blog.
4. Hope that the people you have sent the award to will forward it to their favorite bloggers.

Have fun!

Advertisement

About Anne @ The Frump Factor

Reflections on beauty and style, for women who weren't born yesterday. Bring your sense of humor and "Fight the Frump" with me!
This entry was posted in Fashion, OutfitPosts, Over40 and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

33 Responses to Visible Monday: Rocking a fake pashmina

  1. Kitty says:

    They are ebay for about $6 each, including shipping. At least mine was. And the ones my daughter-in-law ordered for her bridemaids. I just carefully pulled the glued on label off. It makes a little fuztzy spot, but not noticeable.

    My son-in-law recently returned from his deployment in Afghanistan. He was in the southern area (very rural area) near Pakistan. But he brought back beautiful scarves that the vendors were selling to the troops at street markets. They are SO much softer, and SO much warmer than anything I have had before. Now I see why the women can dress like they do with the layers of scarves for warmth! Its all in the fabric weave and content.

  2. notquiteold says:

    I agree, if it looks great and feels wonderful, who cares whether it is a phony. And I love the way you’ve tied it in the last picture. I’m still trying to figure it out, so I can copy it.

  3. Terri says:

    Well, it’s a lovely scarf…and I like how you’ve worn it around your neck. (And just as soon as I’m done typing this, I’m going to go check my pashmina–as I NOW suspect it’s fake). Totally agree with you about Kari’s sense of humor.

  4. Beryl says:

    Nice job knotting that scarf. It looks very European, and not frumpy or old ladyhood worthy at all.
    Just as I was beginning to envy your proximity to that perfect browsing town, I remembered the frozen lipstick tale.

  5. angie says:

    Thanks for tagging me ,it’s my first time .I’m not sure how it goes but I will find the way. Your pashmina has great colors and I beleive it’s the way you style a piece of cloth that makes it modern or old fashion not the cloth per se,So keep on experimenting and stop worrying!

  6. I have one that is fake! This is a really pretty one and I think a shawl can be very sophisticated and not ageing at all…depending on what you pair it with. I have to go check out HAGFEST…I also think the name is hysterical!
    Happy Monday!!

  7. Cynthia says:

    I go to a consignment boutique that has multiples all the time. Sometimes they receive consignments from other shops, rather than from individuals.

    When I was in India in the 80s, what went by the name “pashmina” there was totally different than these scarves that have been in fad for a while. Pashmina then, seemed to be used to refer to high quality wool (cashmere) items, made in Kashmir and covered with dense chain-stitch embroidery in many colors. I have a “pashmina” jacket of that type that is pretty much too awesome to wear anywhere that I’d ever go but maybe I’ll try to casual it up and wear it this winter.

    Anyway, the eBay sellers just slap the name “pashmina” on everything from India now because, like, Rachel had a pashmina on Friends or something. The soft muted paisley scarves that are everywhere from Target to your local consignment shop are, I think, really called jamevaar woven shawls. Even in India woven goods come at many quality and price points. So your “pashmina” is not fake, it’s just low-end, machine woven and probably partially synthetic materials, and there’s nothing wrong with that as long as you like it.

    • Wow, thanks for all the info! You are so right, and this is part of what fascinates me about scarves — the fact that you can get so many varieties, high end, low end, and medium. One of my other current favorites is from Kohl’s! And I also have a pricey, gifted one. It’s fun how they can all “play,” democratically, together.

  8. Barbara J says:

    That is a beautiful scarf, so who cares about the authenticity. Believe me, no one will be trying to see the label when they’re too knocked out by those colors and the pattern. Thanks for the link to your tying technique. I have a lot of scarves that go unworn because I am useless at the tying part. I must not have any French in my genetic makeup!

  9. gingerR says:

    They do seem to be a staple of street vendors. Sometimes they’ll even take them out of the plastic bag that says “made in China.”

    I like them and it doesn’t matter to me if they’re “fake.” Stuff happens to scarves. They get frayed from being tied around your neck, you leave it in a taxi, it gets mixed up in a coat-room. One thing I’ve learned from experience is that you should either dry-clean them or wash them by hand by themselves. The colors can run when wet.

  10. Gail says:

    They’re sold on every corner in NYC, often 3/$10. Who cares that the scarf is a fake if it works.

  11. Your new scarf is lovely, Anne, and I really like your stylish knot (must review Sal’s video). I chuckled at the part where the shop keeper pointed out that all the young girls were buying the scarves too — like we care : > Thanks so much for linking up to Visible Monday, I appreciate you!

  12. gracefully50 says:

    Happy New Year Anne! I love your scarf…fake or not. Scarves bring so much life to an outfit.

  13. yearstricken says:

    Great post. It’s beautiful. I have one of the very same kind, same brand name. My colleague bought it in Turkey. They were not expensive – he brought back several of them for all of the women in our department. I love it because it’s so warm.

  14. Debbi@WSheAccessorizesWell says:

    I admire your writing ability. Your posts are so interesting to read.
    I am thankful you took the award, you deserve one!
    The scarf is lovely. Remember, only you can see the label, so if it looks and feels good then wear it with pride. I think that it is the confidence one wears an item with that can make it look very expensive even if it was not. You look confident and visible!

  15. Katrina says:

    Funny story about the scarf, and I’m with you on the bottom line. If it looks and feels good, it doesn’t matter to me if the fiber is from a goat, silkworm, or cotton plant, or even a synthetic fiber. I don’t know a single person who would grasp an article of my clothing and announce in shocked tones, “that’s not real pashmina!”

  16. Paula says:

    I used to be a snob when it came to fabrics, but there are so many great synthetics or “fakes” out there now, I’m broadending my horizons! Yours is a perfect example–and such a deal! Enjoy it~
    I have a lot of shawls on the shelf–yes, they make me feel like a LOL–in both ways~
    Happy New Year and congrats on the awards–well deserved!

  17. Gail says:

    Thanks for the award Anne! I am pleased to report that it’s David Bowie’s birthday this week….!!
    Re pashminas, yours is lovely. I have one that also has the stuck-on pashmina label. I once bought a “knock off” (fake) “Rolex” watch when I was on holiday but the metal made my skin sore, so I’ve never partaken of other fake goods.

  18. If it makes you feel as if you’re in the 19th-century Russian novel, I’d say it’s cheap at twice the price! I have picked up a few of this type of scarf, similar label, aware they were not as luxurious fabric as claimed, simply because I liked the print. Yours suits your colouring wonderfully and has a richness that hints at all kinds of mystery (that Russian novel vibe, I guess). Enjoy your find, and Happy New Year!

  19. ariane says:

    Hi Anne!
    Happy New Year – sorry to say that you can buy them in NY, cheap, cheap!
    But it is lovely and i have a few and love them!

    Ariane xxxxx

  20. tamerakitten says:

    Congrats on the award!! The scarf is wonderful–who cares if it’s fake or not…it makes you feel good so it’s priceless

  21. Your scarf is beautiful, and I agree that “shawl” does not equal “old lady”. I’m pretty sure I saw A certain young and lovely princess wearing a large knit shawl with her jeans at the grocery. Shawls and scarves are an easy way to layer an outfit to suit changing temperatures and add color. I don’t worry too much about the fiber content in my accessories. They don’t get hard wear and I’d rather have a wide choice than top quality.

  22. barbara.schieren@gmx.de says:

    Ladies – here is the nonplusultra video how to wrap scarves:
    http://youtu.be/5LYAEz777AU

    Your scarf is very lovely! You can try to remove the label with a very hot iron. Put an old cotton cloth between iron and scarf to avoid to burn the scarf.

  23. Kari. says:

    Awe … thank you. And you know what? Our separated at birth angst continues … I have a really hard time with blogging awards as well (for the exact same reasons!). LOL! and LOL about the scarf. I especially liked your comment about being pretty sure that Pashmina was not a real brand. I snorted my coffee. Thank you again!

  24. I must admit all my “pashminas” come from the streets of New York. Fabulous, fabulous scarves. Every time my mom goes, she usually gets five or six and gives them out as gifts. I couldn’t care less if they’re real or not – the colors, patterns and warmth I get from them are worth it! And I think this scarf looks amazing on you! I bet you’ll find yourself wearing it with everything.

  25. lorena says:

    As long as I like something- well i do not care if it is real or not .
    I have several “pashminas”‘ that are probably related to yours and they keep me warm on work days and bring to life evening gowns.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s